Best Review Guide / Reviews / Home / Pop-up toasters

Best Reviewed Pop-up toasters


1

KitchenAid KMT4116CU 4 Slice Long Slot

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Attractive and stylish design
  • Large slots
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Available in several colors
  • Sound alert for when your toast is ready
ConsCons
  • A bit pricey

One of the best things about the KitchenAid KMT4116CU is its beautiful, elegant and simple design. The toaster comes in several colors so you can choose one that goes with your décor. The toaster has really large slots, a removable crumb tray and all the basic features, including a Keep Warm button, Bagel and Frozen buttons.

Read Review
9.7

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

2

Cuisinart CPT-440

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Luxurious, premium design
  • Beep alert to let you know your toast is ready
  • Extra-wide slots
  • Motorized lift
  • Countdown timer
ConsCons
  • A bit pricey
  • May not brown dark enough for some tastes

The Cuisinart CPT-440 is a high-end toaster, with 4 extra-wide slots, a motorized lift and Bagel, Reheat and Defrost features. It looks very good and stylish in any kitchen and it performs well on every setting. It is not the most affordable toaster out there but you will get your money’s worth.

Read Review
9.7

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

3

Smeg 2-slice

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Attractive, vintage design
  • Comes in several colors
  • Solid construction
  • Time and energy efficient
  • Removable crumb tray
ConsCons
  • A bit pricey
  • The exterior gets too hot when in use

The Smeg 2 slice is an Italian made toaster with a very attractive vintage design. It is simple but has all the basic functions, it is fast and toasts your bread evenly. Its drawbacks are the fact that it gets very hot when in use and it is quite an expensive appliance.

Read Review
9.6

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

4

Dualit 4 slot New Gen

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Interesting retro design
  • Very durable
  • Award winning patented ProHeat elements
  • Fast
  • Can heat only the slots you are using
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Wide range of colors available
ConsCons
  • Very expensive
  • Manual controls might not be for everyone
  • No Cancel or Reheat buttons
  • Bulky and heavy

In spite of its ‘New Gen’ name, the Dualit toaster is a very vintage looking toaster which you either love or completely dislike. It is handmade in the UK, it has a manual timer and lever, it is extremely durable, it is very fast but it lacks some common features found in most toasters. It is also very expensive.

Read Review
9.5

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

5

Oster Jelly Bean 2-slice

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Very cute and colorful
  • Extremely affordable
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Useful Frozen feature that performed better than in a lot of much pricier toasters
ConsCons
  • Doesn’t always toast evenly
  • The Bagel function leaves room for improvement

The Jelly Bean 2 slice from Oster is among the cutest toasters on the market. It is small yet solid and it is one of the best choices for people on a budget. It has a Frozen, Bagel and Warm function and removable crumb tray.

Read Review
9.1

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

6

Cuisinart CPT-3000 ViewPro Glass 2

Product Image
ProsPros
  • See-through design with removable glass panels
  • Slots are really wide
  • Responsive touch controls
  • Toasts evenly
  • Removable crumb tray
ConsCons
  • No sound alert when toast is ready
  • No Keep Warm function

The Cuisinart ViewPro Glass 2 is a modern 2-slice toaster, with touch controls and see-through glass windows that let you see the slices inside. Its extra-wide slots let you toast even the thickest bagels/slices and the Quartz technology make sure your bread will get toasted evenly.

Read Review
9.0

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

7

Breville Bit More BTA720XL 2-Slice

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Durable
  • Stainless steel body
  • The Bit More function
  • Sound alert that can be adjusted or muted
  • Doesn’t take up too much space
  • Affordable
  • Removable crumb tray
ConsCons
  • No Reheat feature
  • Gets hot when in use
  • A bit slow

As its name suggests it, the Breville BTA720XL toaster stands out through its special ‘A Bit More’ function which allows you to crisp your bread for an extra half a minute, regardless of the setting that you are using. The Bit More 2-slice model has a high-end design, very simple controls and a durable construction. It comes at a decent price and it toasts your items evenly every time.

Read Review
8.9

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

8

Krups Savoy KH3110

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Tasteful design
  • Solid
  • Affordable
  • Toasts evenly
  • Removable crumb tray
ConsCons
  • Gets hot when in use
  • Slow

The Krups Savoy KH3110 is another well-made toaster in which the German standard can easily be seen and felt. The toaster has a 2 slice capacity, looks tasteful yet solid, and toasts your bread evenly, although a bit slower than some competitors. It is really affordable and overall, a great value for the money.

Read Review
8.8

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

9

Bonsaii T866 4-Slice

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Large capacity; can accommodate various types of bread
  • Affordable
  • Fast
  • Toasts evenly
ConsCons
  • Has a strong smell when you first unbox it
  • The housing gets hotter than average
  • The bread doesn’t pop up high enough
  • No Reheat option

The Bonsaii T866 is a 4-slice toaster with a nice stainless steel housing and simple controls. It won’t sweep you off your feet but it will perform well for the money. It toasts evenly and fast, it is easy to use and to clean. It does leave room for improvement when it comes to those details that make the difference, but at this price, it is definitely a bargain.  

Read Review
8.7

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.

10

KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slice

Product Image
ProsPros
  • Attractive design
  • Durable, solid
  • Two independent toasting zones/control panels
  • Extra-large slots
  • Removable crumb trays for each section
ConsCons
  • Slower than other toasters
  • A bit too large for some kitchens

The Krups KH734D50 is a German toaster suited for family use. It is a generous 4-slice model with two separate toasting zones and independent control panels. It is sturdy, quite large, good looking and durable. It is a bit slower than other toasters, but it compensates in features and quality.

Read Review
8.3

Check Price


Our editorial staff evaluates products and services independently, but Best Review Guide may earn money when you click on links. Learn more.


Last updated June 18, 2019

All About Pop-up Toasters

Your toaster is that kitchen appliance you don’t really think about too much, but if a kitchen isn’t equipped with one, you immediately feel something’s missing. Toasters are reliable helpers whether you want to prepare a quick sandwich or simply to give a special flavor to your slice of bread, no matter what you serve it with.

They are essential appliances, especially for that on the clock breakfast when you need to eat something fast but healthy, before work.

Although toasters are not new in our lifestyles, as they have been invented two centuries ago, in 1893, they are still very popular. While they were initially developed in Scotland, today you can find them on nearly every shelf throughout the world.

How do pop-out toasters work?

The pop-out toasters have a pretty simple mechanism. Inside there’s a heating element made of nickel-chromium alloy. This is what radiates heat on the slice of bread and toasts it. In order to obtain a gold, medium toast, the heat must reach around 310 degrees Fahrenheit. If the temperature rises too much, a carbonization effect occurs and the slice becomes burnt.

Types of toasters

The most common way to classify toasters is based on their functionality and capacity.

Based on their capacity, or how many slices of bread you can fit in them (how many slots they have), there are 2 slices toasters, 4 slices, 6 slices, 8 slices toasters and even above.

Based on their use, there are three basic types of toasters:

  • Pop-up toasters, which are the most common and affordable ones, is what most of us have in our kitchens. They are used for toasting your bread or maybe a bagel. There are called ‘pop-up’ because of their spring that is released when your slice is ready and pops up. This way it is easier for you to get the slice of bread out without burning yourself. It is usually the cheapest and smallest type of toaster, so you can easily find a place for it even if you have a smaller kitchen. Another benefit of the pop-up toasters is that they toast your slice evenly.
  • Toaster ovens: they are basically electric ovens only smaller, although they still take up more space than a pop-up toaster. They are also pricier than the aforementioned ones. You can still find smaller toaster ovens, if you know space is a problem for you, but you should also keep in mind that its capacity will also be smaller, and you might not be able to fit more than 5 slices of bread in it. Toaster ovens are very versatile, you can use them not just to toast your slices of bread but also bagels, muffins, to bake, make your pizza, broil and brown your food. They have a small front door, a baking pan which can be removed and wire racks. Some people get a toaster oven instead of a regular oven.
  • Conveyor toasters: they are mostly used in restaurants and the catering industry in general, because they are the largest type and can toast at a rate of 300-1600 slices of bread/hour.

There are also specialized toasters out there: bagel toasters, egg and muffin toasters, hot dog toasters and others.

Toasters also come in a plethora of designs, shapes, colors and materials. They can have a brushed metal, chrome, copper finish and more.

In terms of power, most 2-slices toasters have a power of 850 watts, while 4-slices toasters between 1400W and 2300W.

Pop-up Toasters - What To Look For

The market is flooded with toasters, in different shapes, sizes, colors, models, brands and price ranges. It is the kind of kitchen appliance you find in every store and it can be exhausting to figure out which one works best for you. Here’s a quick guide to help you make the best decision when in the market for a new pop-up toaster.

Establish your budget. Toasters vary widely in price. You can buy a toaster for under $30, or you can pay hundreds of dollars on it, depending on the brand, quality, size and features. Decide whether you want just a simple, basic 2-slices toaster, or you are willing to pay extra and get all the bells and whistles.

Capacity. Do you need a toaster just for you and maybe your spouse, or do you have a large family of toast eaters you have to take care of all at once? If you know you’re making a lot of toast, you should opt for at least a 4-slices pop-up toaster, if not for an even bigger one (6-slices, 8-slices). Of course, you have to also consider your available space, as a 4 or 6-slices toaster will definitely take-up more space than a 2-slices one.

Look for a model that has a slide-out/removable crumb tray. Over time, your toaster will get filled with crumbs that need to be emptied, so you don’t risk a fire hazard. If the toaster has a hinged crumb tray, you’ll have to hold the entire toaster above the sink/bin to shake the crumbs out, so look for a model with a removable tray.

Materials. Aside from the effect it has on its looks, the material of the body is also an important aspect in terms of durability. Cheaper, less durable toasters usually come in a plastic body, whereas the more solid, premium pop-up toasters have a metallic or chrome finish. Also, as a side note, plastic toasters tend to heat up faster.

Features. This is probably among the most important aspects to consider when choosing a toaster. Toasters come loaded with a plethora of features, some more essential than others. Here are the most important features to have in a toaster:

  • Cancel function: most toasters on the market today have this feature that allows you to stop the toasting-cycle, if you feel your slice is getting too toasted or burnt
  • Reheat: it is a useful feature for when you want to reheat your slice of bread but without drying it too much
  • Defrost: this feature is handy if you have frozen bread
  • Countdown timer: it shows you how much time you have to wait for your slice to pop-up
  • Browning control: this is the most basic feature and all toasters include it. It allows you to adjust the level of toasting. While some toasters have the three, classic settings (light, medium, dark), others have a numbered system (from 1 to 5 for instance), LEDs that indicate the level or even different colors
  • Insulated housing: this feature may be important to you especially if you have kids, because toasters that have an insulated exterior don’t get hot, not even when they are in use
  • Pause option or ‘lift and look’ that allows you to pause the toasting cycle to check the progress
  • Hi-lift: It is useful when you have smaller slices of bread because it raises the bread carriage higher so that you can get the slices out without burning yourself
  • Bagel setting: they allow you to toast only one side of the bagel and keep the other one soft. If you want to be able to toast bagels you should look for a model that has larger slots, so that you can fit a bagel in it

There are a lot of choices when it comes to toasters. Some of the most appreciated and renowned toaster brands out there are Cuisinart, Krups, KitchenAid, DeLonghi, Black+Decker, Hamilton Beach, Oster, Breville, Philips, Brevo, Gourmia, Sunbeam.